Gibson Banjo

Guitar and banjo "hardware"- why are the tuners differently designed?

Can someone please enlighten me on an interesting point. I have recently replaced the tuners on a guitar and a banjo and I was struck that both instruments are broadly similar yet the preferred tuner design is quite different.

I should point out I am talking about "top of the range" type instruments here. For instance, take a good quality banjo. It will have geared tuning "pegs" which come straight out the back of the instrument. Conversely a good quality guitar will have tuners - Grovers or such- which have handles which come out at 90 degrees.

I know that many cheap or "old time" banjos also use guitar type tuners but never have I seen the reverse situation- where banjo type tuning pegs are used on a guitar. Is there any reason why this should be?

Please PLEASE note that this is a specific question about banjo tuning pags and guitar tuners. I don't invite correspondence form people droning on about their gibson banjos, martin D28's or whatever.

I dunno , history of both instruments is probably a weak factor , maybe a luthier in here can answer the direct question while avoiding all the ambiguity of it all - MY simple (mostly non sufficient) answer would be "cause it's just like that , and thats the way it is..." LOL!

Discover Gibson Banjo On eBay Below:

C1920s Vintage The Gibson Kalamazoo Banjo Mandolin Serial No 8946 11 Banjolin
C1920s Vintage The Gibson Kalamazoo Banjo Mandolin Serial No 8946 11 Banjolin
$289.99
Nice Antique Gibson Tenor or Ukulele Banjo with Rare Wilmot Wood Resonator
Nice Antique Gibson Tenor or Ukulele Banjo with Rare Wilmot Wood Resonator
$464.46
NOS Banjo Mandolin Violin Uke  Guitar Strings Gibson LaBella etc in Packages
NOS Banjo Mandolin Violin Uke Guitar Strings Gibson LaBella etc in Packages
$40.39
1988 Gibson Bluegrass Banjo  Mandolin Brochure Case Candy
1988 Gibson Bluegrass Banjo Mandolin Brochure Case Candy
$9.95
Gibson Copy RB 3 Vintage used banjo with case
Gibson Copy RB 3 Vintage used banjo with case
$700.00
24 VINTAGE GIBSON BANJO HOOKS AND NUTS 1930S EXCELLENT
24 VINTAGE GIBSON BANJO HOOKS AND NUTS 1930S EXCELLENT
$259.00
Vintage Gibson Kalamazoo Banjo Mandolin Banjolin By Gibson
Vintage Gibson Kalamazoo Banjo Mandolin Banjolin By Gibson
$749.00
Prewar Grover two band tuners Gibson Vega and other banjos
Prewar Grover two band tuners Gibson Vega and other banjos
$450.00
arm rest from a Gibson banjo 1930s
arm rest from a Gibson banjo 1930s
$450.00
Gibson RB 170 RB170 5 string Banjo Guitar Long Neck Used 1962 Vintage Rare
Gibson RB 170 RB170 5 string Banjo Guitar Long Neck Used 1962 Vintage Rare
$2,910.90
1950s Gibson Tenor banjo case
1950s Gibson Tenor banjo case
$50.00
late 20 to early 30s Gibson TB 1 Tenor Banjo Conversion
late 20 to early 30s Gibson TB 1 Tenor Banjo Conversion
$795.00
ANTIQUE VINTAGE GIBSON OR VEGA TENOR BANJO CASE
ANTIQUE VINTAGE GIBSON OR VEGA TENOR BANJO CASE
$75.99
Vintage The Gibson UB1  Ukulele Banjo 20s  Beautiful Instrument
Vintage The Gibson UB1 Ukulele Banjo 20s Beautiful Instrument
$699.99
1925 Gibson Banjo Mastertone Neck 4 string tenor style TB3 TB 3
1925 Gibson Banjo Mastertone Neck 4 string tenor style TB3 TB 3
$350.00
VINTAGE ARTiSO BANJO SUPER NICE BEST OF KIND 1920s with OLD GIBSON case
VINTAGE ARTiSO BANJO SUPER NICE BEST OF KIND 1920s with OLD GIBSON case
$895.00
Vintage 1970s Music store Catalog Gibson Guitar banjo mandolin Case Candy Parts
Vintage 1970s Music store Catalog Gibson Guitar banjo mandolin Case Candy Parts
$29.00
Gibson Classic Trap Door Tenor Banjo TB Model
Gibson Classic Trap Door Tenor Banjo TB Model
$895.00
1940 50s The Michigan Banjo  ESTATE FIND
1940 50s The Michigan Banjo ESTATE FIND
$175.00
1920s Vintage Gibson UB 1 Banjo Ukulele Very Clean
1920s Vintage Gibson UB 1 Banjo Ukulele Very Clean
$689.00
VINTAGE 1964 USA GIBSON TB BANJO STRING NUT 1965
VINTAGE 1964 USA GIBSON TB BANJO STRING NUT 1965
$79.00
Gibson Junior Vintage 1920s TB JR Tenor 4 String Banjo Natural Finish with Case
Gibson Junior Vintage 1920s TB JR Tenor 4 String Banjo Natural Finish with Case
$858.48
1920s Vintage Gibson UB 1 Banjo Ukulele With Coffin Case Nice Video
1920s Vintage Gibson UB 1 Banjo Ukulele With Coffin Case Nice Video
$679.00
Gibson RB 100 Banjo 5 string built 1954 excellent condition
Gibson RB 100 Banjo 5 string built 1954 excellent condition
$1,900.00
GIBSON JUNIOR VINTAGE 1920s MB JR BANJOLIN MANDOLIN BANJO w CASE
GIBSON JUNIOR VINTAGE 1920s MB JR BANJOLIN MANDOLIN BANJO w CASE
$299.00
Gibson RB 250 w case Banjo 581
Gibson RB 250 w case Banjo 581
$3,580.00
VINTAGE 1974 1920s 1930s GIBSON Florentine granda Banjo catalog reissue 1970s
VINTAGE 1974 1920s 1930s GIBSON Florentine granda Banjo catalog reissue 1970s
$39.00
Gibson RB 175 60s w case Banjo 581
Gibson RB 175 60s w case Banjo 581
$1,882.00
Factory Fresh Condition 1964 Gibson RB 175 Long Neck Pete Seeger Banjo
Factory Fresh Condition 1964 Gibson RB 175 Long Neck Pete Seeger Banjo
$1,150.00
Original 1969 Gibson Mastertone Banjo Head
Original 1969 Gibson Mastertone Banjo Head
$49.99
Gibson TB 0 banjo 1925 FON 8004 22
Gibson TB 0 banjo 1925 FON 8004 22
$375.00
Gibson replacement banjo neck
Gibson replacement banjo neck
$695.00


Recently Purchased Gibson Banjo:


1920s the gibson ub1 banjo ukulele banjolele, antique vintage gibson or vega tenor banjo case, vintage rare gibson mastertone banjo wrench, 1950s gibson tenor banjo case, 1964 gibson rb175 open back long neck banjo 24 frets 5string, gibson tb4 ball bearing 1925 brown original pot, c1920s vintage the gibson kalamazoo banjo mandolin serial no 8946 11 banjolin, 24 vintage gibson banjo hooks and nuts 1930s excellent , gibson copy rb3 vintage used banjo with case, gibson rb170 rb170 5string banjo guitar long neck used 1962 vintage rare, 1988 gibson bluegrass banjo amp; mandolin brochure case candy, rare late 50s gibson rb150 bowtie 5 string archtop banjo amp; original case, nice antique gibson tenor or ukulele banjo with rare wilmot wood resonator, gibson tb0 banjo 1925 fon 800422, factory fresh condition 1964 gibson rb175 long neck pete seeger banjo, gibson rb175 60s wcase banjo581, gibson rb250 wcase banjo581, 194050s the michigan banjo estate find , gibson classic trap door tenor banjo tb model, vintage the gibson ub1 ukulele banjo 20s beautiful instrument, arm rest from a gibson banjo 1930s, prewar grover two band tuners gibson vega and other banjos, nos banjo mandolin violin uke amp; guitar strings gibson labella etc in packages, vintage gibson rb250 mastertone resonator 5string banjo amp; case reduced, gibson junior vintage 1920s mb jr banjolin mandolin banjo w case, 1920s vintage gibson ub1 banjo ukulele very clean, 1925 gibson banjo mastertone neck 4 string tenor style tb3 tb3, vintage gibson kalamazoo banjo mandolin banjolin by gibson, 1926 gibson mastertone gb3 6 string guitar banjo wcase, original 1969 gibson mastertone banjo head, replacement 5sring banjo neck for gibson and other one piece flange banjos, gibson replacement banjo neck, vintage 1970s music store catalog gibson guitar banjo mandolin case candy parts , vintage antique banjo tuners grover patent diamond gibson bamp;d kay parts, vintage 1974 1920s 1930s gibson florentine granda banjo catalog reissue 1970s , gibson rb100 banjo 5 string built 1954 excellent condition , 1920s vintage gibson ub1 banjo ukulele with coffin case nice video, vintage artiso banjo super nice best of kind 1920s with old gibson case, gibson junior vintage 1920s tb jr tenor 4 string banjo natural finish with case, vintage gibson mona steel tenor banjo string boxes with strings usa kalamazoo , vintage 1964 usa gibson tb banjo string nut 1965, late 20 to early 30s gibson tb1 tenor banjo conversion



Comments are closed.