Gibson Banjo

Guitar and banjo "hardware"- why are the tuners differently designed?

Can someone please enlighten me on an interesting point. I have recently replaced the tuners on a guitar and a banjo and I was struck that both instruments are broadly similar yet the preferred tuner design is quite different.

I should point out I am talking about "top of the range" type instruments here. For instance, take a good quality banjo. It will have geared tuning "pegs" which come straight out the back of the instrument. Conversely a good quality guitar will have tuners - Grovers or such- which have handles which come out at 90 degrees.

I know that many cheap or "old time" banjos also use guitar type tuners but never have I seen the reverse situation- where banjo type tuning pegs are used on a guitar. Is there any reason why this should be?

Please PLEASE note that this is a specific question about banjo tuning pags and guitar tuners. I don't invite correspondence form people droning on about their gibson banjos, martin D28's or whatever.

I dunno , history of both instruments is probably a weak factor , maybe a luthier in here can answer the direct question while avoiding all the ambiguity of it all - MY simple (mostly non sufficient) answer would be "cause it's just like that , and thats the way it is..." LOL!

Discover Gibson Banjo On eBay Below:

gibson banjo flange
gibson banjo flange
$35.00
VGUC TENOR BANJO Gibson ca 1935 TB 11
VGUC TENOR BANJO Gibson ca 1935 TB 11
$3,200.00
The Gibson authentic mandolin banjo
The Gibson authentic mandolin banjo
$999.00
Vintage 1923 Gibson Style 4 Tenor Banjo
Vintage 1923 Gibson Style 4 Tenor Banjo
$1,000.00
11 Mounted Hide Banjo Head High Crown Fits GIBSON Archtop  Others
11 Mounted Hide Banjo Head High Crown Fits GIBSON Archtop Others
$1.00
Vintage Gibson Banjo tenor trapdoor 1921 TB00 with case
Vintage Gibson Banjo tenor trapdoor 1921 TB00 with case
$499.99
Gibson UB 1 Ukulele Banjo Banjolele Excellent Condition
Gibson UB 1 Ukulele Banjo Banjolele Excellent Condition
$66.00
GIBSON 1927 Tenor Banjo in original case Fully Functional
GIBSON 1927 Tenor Banjo in original case Fully Functional
$899.00
The Gibson banjo 1920 4 strings serial  11054A 84 open
The Gibson banjo 1920 4 strings serial 11054A 84 open
$800.00
VINTAGE 1920s 1930s Pre War GIBSON The Bacon Banjo catalog 1970s reissue LOT 7
VINTAGE 1920s 1930s Pre War GIBSON The Bacon Banjo catalog 1970s reissue LOT 7
$135.00
1930s GIBSON TB 00 tenor banjo with hard shell case
1930s GIBSON TB 00 tenor banjo with hard shell case
$1,595.00
GIBSON EARL SCRUGGS MASTERTONE BANJO WITH CASE
GIBSON EARL SCRUGGS MASTERTONE BANJO WITH CASE
$3,450.00
NOS Banjo Mandolin Violin Uke  Guitar Strings Gibson LaBella etc in Packages
NOS Banjo Mandolin Violin Uke Guitar Strings Gibson LaBella etc in Packages
$40.39
Vintage Gibson Mandolin  Banjo Strings Hand Made Set
Vintage Gibson Mandolin Banjo Strings Hand Made Set
$8.00
late 20 to early 30s Gibson TB 1 Tenor Banjo Conversion
late 20 to early 30s Gibson TB 1 Tenor Banjo Conversion
$795.00
Set of Vintage 4 String Rickenbacker Martin Gibson Banjo Tuners Pegs for Project
Set of Vintage 4 String Rickenbacker Martin Gibson Banjo Tuners Pegs for Project
$100.00
1955 Gibson RB 100 Banjo All Original and Uncut
1955 Gibson RB 100 Banjo All Original and Uncut
$1,825.00
1929 Gibson RB 3 Banjo
1929 Gibson RB 3 Banjo
$8,300.00
Antique Gibson Banjo 11573 3 Restoration Project
Antique Gibson Banjo 11573 3 Restoration Project
$400.00
GIBSON RB 250 MASTERTONE 108316
GIBSON RB 250 MASTERTONE 108316
$1,300.00
Gibson vintage tenor banjo
Gibson vintage tenor banjo
$1,050.00
Set of Vintage 30s Grover Patented Martin Gibson Banjo Geared Tuners Project
Set of Vintage 30s Grover Patented Martin Gibson Banjo Geared Tuners Project
$95.00
1925 Gibson Banjo Mastertone Neck 4 string tenor style TB3 TB 3
1925 Gibson Banjo Mastertone Neck 4 string tenor style TB3 TB 3
$350.00
Vintage Gibson Mastertone Banjo Wrench Key Tool
Vintage Gibson Mastertone Banjo Wrench Key Tool
$79.99
VINTAGE ARTiSO BANJO SUPER NICE BEST OF KIND 1920s with OLD GIBSON case
VINTAGE ARTiSO BANJO SUPER NICE BEST OF KIND 1920s with OLD GIBSON case
$849.00
Vintage 1970s Music store Catalog Gibson Guitar banjo mandolin Case Candy Parts
Vintage 1970s Music store Catalog Gibson Guitar banjo mandolin Case Candy Parts
$29.00
banjo tail piece Kerschner unique for gibson and others
banjo tail piece Kerschner unique for gibson and others
$150.00
LANGE Challenger 4 string Resonator BANJO with CASE Used Vintage
LANGE Challenger 4 string Resonator BANJO with CASE Used Vintage
$1,000.00
Vintage Gibson Banjolin Alabama Cotton Picker 1932
Vintage Gibson Banjolin Alabama Cotton Picker 1932
$1,000.00
Vintage 20s Gibson Banjolin
Vintage 20s Gibson Banjolin
$700.00
1920s Vintage Gibson UB 1 Banjo Ukulele Very Clean
1920s Vintage Gibson UB 1 Banjo Ukulele Very Clean
$689.00
Vintage 1920s Gibson Banjolin Banjo Mandolin
Vintage 1920s Gibson Banjolin Banjo Mandolin
$1,800.00


Recently Purchased Gibson Banjo:


1968 gibson rb250 mastertone 5 string banjo w ohsc, gibson bango 1967 rb100 5string, vintage gibson mandolin amp; banjo strings hand made set, gibson earl scruggs mastertone banjo with case, 1930s gibson tb00 tenor banjo with hard shell case, gibson rb250 mastertone 108316, the gibson mandolin banjo banjolin mb excellent vintage condition rare 62, vintage 1970s gibson banjo case for tenor banjo, gibson ub1 ukulele banjo banjolele excellent condition, vintage gibson banjo tenor trapdoor 1921 tb00 with case , 1929 gibson tb3 5 string conversion banjo opf neat neck blaylock ring w case, 1930s gibson tb11 kel kroydon 5 string conversion banjo blaylock ring case, 11 mounted hide banjo headhigh crownfits gibson archtop amp; others, gibson classic trap door tenor banjo tb model, the gibson authentic mandolin banjo, gibson vintage banjo tb250 bowtie archtop, gibson earl scruggs mastertone banjo the real dealthe gibson case look, 1930s gibson tb11 conversion banjo, vintage 1920s gibson banjolin banjo mandolin, vintage 20s gibson banjolin, vintage gibson banjolin €alabama cotton picker 1932€, lange challenger 4string resonator banjo with case used vintage, set of vintage 30s grover patented martin gibson banjo geared tuners project, antique gibson banjo 115733 restoration project, 1955 gibson rb 100 banjo all original and uncut, set of vintage 4string rickenbacker martin gibson banjo tuners pegs for project, nos banjo mandolin violin uke amp; guitar strings gibson labella etc in packages, the gibson banjo 1920 4 strings serial 11054a 84 open, gibson 1927 tenor banjo in original case fully functional, vintage 1923 gibson style 4 tenor banjo, gibson banjo flange, prewar grover two band tuners gibson vega and other banjos, gibson mastertone banjo 5 string 1970s rb250 rb250 series w ohc 1969, banjo tail piece kerschner unique for gibson and others, vintage gibson mastertone banjo wrench key tool, vguc tenor banjo gibson ca 1935 tb11, gibson vintage tenor banjo, gibson junior tenor banjo vintage 1923, 1925 gibson tb trap door convertible tenor banjo gia0754 , 1929 gibson rb3 banjo, vintage 1926 pre war gibson mandobanjo pot, 1930s gibson kalamazoo four string banjo with resonator case and manuals, vintage 1920s 1930s pre war gibson the bacon banjo catalog 1970s reissue lot 7, 1920s vintage gibson ub1 banjo ukulele very clean, 1925 gibson banjo mastertone neck 4 string tenor style tb3 tb3, 1926 gibson mastertone gb3 6 string guitar banjo wcase, replacement 5sring banjo neck for gibson and other one piece flange banjos, vintage 1970s music store catalog gibson guitar banjo mandolin case candy parts , gibson rb100 banjo 5 string built 1954 excellent condition , vintage artiso banjo super nice best of kind 1920s with old gibson case, gibson junior vintage 1920s tb jr tenor 4 string banjo natural finish with case, vintage gibson mona steel tenor banjo string boxes with strings usa kalamazoo , vintage 1964 usa gibson tb banjo string nut 1965, late 20 to early 30s gibson tb1 tenor banjo conversion



Comments are closed.